indianaphotography.info
Photo Detective
Home | Only a Test | Bio & Mission | Our Products | Business expansion plans | GALLERY of Indiana shots | GALLERY of Mid-Atlantic shots | Sneak Preview | IndyBoom | Historic Cotton Mill | I-69 Extention Views | Barns of Indiana 2 | Photo Detective | Contact Us | BOC

Silas McGuffers occasionally runs across photos in print that are misascribed or uncredited, or, has taken pictures that shed light on mysteries.  This page highlights such instances in the interest of setting the record straight.

An image that has appeared in print at least once and continues to show up on television features and documentaries is one that was originally taken outside of Horton, Kansas between l935 and l940 by J.W."Wes" McManigal, appearing in the l974 Stephen Greene Press (originally of Brattleboro, VT) book, "Farm Town."

Farm Town, A Memoir of the l930s
farmtowncover.jpg
Stephen Greene Press: imprint of Viking Penguin div of Penguin Putnam, Inc., NY NY 800 331-4624

This book happens to be one of the best photo documentaries of farm and small town life of this era that exists, in quality of pictures and subject matter (both as stand-alone art and in context).  Truly heartwarming and wholesomely nostalgic.  [availability unknown]  In it on page 20 is the following picture:  (of higher quality than appears here, due to Moire problems)

Farm outside of Horton, Kansas
thefarmoriginal.jpg
Farm Town, p. 20, Stephen Greene Press, l974

The Indiana University Press published a book, "A Pictorial History of Indiana," by Dwight W. Hoover in l980 (below).

A Pictorial History of Indiana
pictoralhistcover.jpg
Indiana University Press, l980

In this book is the following picture on page 114:

NOT Purdue University's farm's barn.....
Purdue barn NOT Pictorial History of Indiana 1980
A Pictorial History of Indiana, p 114, Indiana University Press, l980

Though Purdue indeed had and has numerous experimental farms, barns and properties, this particular barn should never again appear in print or on TV being passed off as being theirs or located in Indiana now that the truth be known! 

The Why of the Why Store

An Indiana band that had some success a few years ago with, among other songs, "Lack Of Water," has* (*yes, they're back together: http://shafferstreet.com/whystore/board-temp.htm ) an interesting-bordering-on-inscrutable name, namely, The Why Store.  What The Who The Why That?  ...One day after putting this addition to Photo Detective on this site, bragging about how I "solved" the mystery by spotting the store below, and also putting a post on the band's message board, I received an email from Michael Smith, Why Store lead guitarist, correcting me.  MDS:  "...we got our name by seeing it painted on the outside of an old store in Muncie, IN.  I even have some of the original stationary from TWS.   Originally, we thought it would be a great name for an album, as our name at the time was "Emerald City".  We thought The Why Store had a certain ring to it and there you go!  please let your webviewers know it is a fitting tribute to a great piece of Indiana Americana!   P.S.  There is also a "why" store in London, England!"   He also states that the group was witness to seeing the Muncie store demolished.  The pictures below are of a "ghost sign" on the back of what was a like-named shoe and clothing store in Worthington, Indiana, most likely a part of this defunct Indiana chain, and was taken in October, 2002. As it is probably the only survivor still standing, it is suggested that you direct any fan pilgrimages to it, a "3rd class relic" substitute for the original inspiration.... 

The Why Of The Why Store Of Worthington
CopyrightSilasMcGuffers888.484.3749.POB130.IN46113
Why, it's the closest non-living kin of the nomenclatural inspiration for the band, The Why Store

C-U ON Y
CopyrightSilasMcGuffers888.484.3749.POB130.IN46113
Why Store? ...What? ...No, Why! ...Who? ...Guess Who! ...Yes? ...No! ...Why Not? (...Who's on 1st?)